Fudge Set: 1 Slice

$8.95
(5 reviews) Write a Review
Minimum Purchase:
1 unit
Maximum Purchase:
5 units
1 Flavor Fudge Set with box

Want to send that special gift to that special someone? Send them a full slice of fudge from our assortment of flavors. A popular recommendation: Chocolate Nut, Blueberry, Chocolate Peanut Butter or Mint Chocolate Chip! Or choose from our most popular flavors*:

  • Chocolate Nut
  • Plain Chocolate
  • Vanilla Nut
  • Maple Nut
  • Peanut Butter
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Double Chocolate
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Amaretto Chocolate Chip
  • Rum Walnut
  • Coconut
  • Bluberry
  • Cherry
  • Pumpkin
  • Sea Salt Caramel

*Fudge flavors will be available to order when there is enough stock.

5 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Cherry Fudge

    Posted by Lucille on 2nd Sep 2016

    Chock-full of cherries and super creamy!
    Delicious cherry flavor.










  • 5
    Everything that I hoped it would be.

    Posted by Unknown on 29th Jul 2014

    It is hard to find really excellent Vanilla Nut Fudge !

  • 2
    Purchased Blueberry Fudge...

    Posted by Dan P. on 15th Oct 2013

    Sorry, but it was not fudge as I would call it. It was tacky, and pasty. I put in refrigerator, but did not make it any better. Flavor was okay, but I would not purchase the blueberry fudge again.

  • 5
    The best fudge around!

    Posted by Unknown on 27th Aug 2013

    We sent a slice of the maple nut fudge to our daughter in another state. It arrived promptly, and in very good condition. She enjoyed the taste of the fudge, it was excellent.

  • 5
    Creamy!!

    Posted by Unknown on 13th Aug 2013

    My wife and I have looked for several years around Mackinaw City. We were on the Island recently and found May's Candy and Fudge Shop. We tasted the fudge and we both agreed that this fudge is some of the very best that we have ever tasted. It is creamy and not too sweet. Of course, we bought a slice to take with us. We will definitely be buying more. By the way, we just ordered the 9 flavor set and can't hardly wait until it arrives.