Fudge Set: 3 Slices

Available Summer 2019

(18 reviews) Write a Review
Minimum Purchase:
1 unit
Maximum Purchase:
10 units

Our most popular fudge package set! Select three fudge flavors* from our popular list:

  • Chocolate Nut
  • Plain Chocolate
  • Vanilla Nut
  • Maple Nut
  • Peanut Butter
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Double Chocolate
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Amaretto Chocolate Chip
  • Rum Walnut
  • Coconut
  • Bluberry
  • Cherry
  • Pumpkin
  • Sea Salt Caramel

*Fudge flavors will be available to order when there is enough stock.

18 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Loved the candy..packing didn’t hold up well when delivered. A little smashed,

    Posted by Eleanor chaffin on 17th Aug 2018

    I only got to eat a litte, because my husband enjoyed it so much, he beat me to it. Anyway i am glad that i got it for him.

  • 5
    fudge 3 slices

    Posted by Susan Miller on 15th Aug 2018

    fudge was very fresh and delicious

  • 5
    2 different kinds of fudge

    Posted by Mary Berry on 28th Jul 2018

    I love May's Fudge is the closest to the fudge my mom used to make.
    When I can't make it up to the Island, this is the best way to get my "fudge cravings ".
    Will be ordering again b/4 the end of season

  • 5
    Mats dydfe

    Posted by Bob on 21st Jul 2018

    Always great

  • 5
    Fudge

    Posted by Melanie on 13th Jul 2018

    Online purchase was easy to use. Fudge arrived quickly, in excellent condition. Fresh and as good as if I'd picked it up in person.
    Maple nut is outstanding!

  • 5
    The Best as always

    Posted by Wythe Winchester on 7th Jul 2018

    only 4.99 stars because when I worked on the island the fudge that Marvin and Carl made coming off the paddle warm and creamy was the absolute best.

  • 5
    Candy

    Posted by Unknown on 27th Oct 2017

    Very good what I wanted

  • 5
    Vanilla Nut Fudge

    Posted by Laura Jones on 21st Sep 2017

    I've sent this fudge as a gift several times to a friend. This is his favorite flavor, and not everyone makes it.

  • 5
    Fudge

    Posted by Barbara Solar on 13th Aug 2017

    Mays fudge shop is the best, when I hadn't received my order when expected they immediately sent the order express and an extra slice for the inconvenience. The fudge was phenomenal .