Fudge Set: 3 Slices

(14 reviews) Write a Review
Minimum Purchase:
1 unit
Maximum Purchase:
10 units

Our most popular fudge package set! Select three fudge flavors* from our popular list:

  • Chocolate Nut
  • Plain Chocolate
  • Vanilla Nut
  • Maple Nut
  • Peanut Butter
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Double Chocolate
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Amaretto Chocolate Chip
  • Rum Walnut
  • Coconut
  • Bluberry
  • Cherry
  • Pumpkin
  • Sea Salt Caramel

*Fudge flavors will be available to order when there is enough stock.

14 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Melanie on 13th Jul 2018

    Online purchase was easy to use. Fudge arrived quickly, in excellent condition. Fresh and as good as if I'd picked it up in person.
    Maple nut is outstanding!

  • 5
    The Best as always

    Posted by Wythe Winchester on 7th Jul 2018

    only 4.99 stars because when I worked on the island the fudge that Marvin and Carl made coming off the paddle warm and creamy was the absolute best.

  • 5

    Posted by Unknown on 27th Oct 2017

    Very good what I wanted

  • 5
    Vanilla Nut Fudge

    Posted by Laura Jones on 21st Sep 2017

    I've sent this fudge as a gift several times to a friend. This is his favorite flavor, and not everyone makes it.

  • 5

    Posted by Barbara Solar on 13th Aug 2017

    Mays fudge shop is the best, when I hadn't received my order when expected they immediately sent the order express and an extra slice for the inconvenience. The fudge was phenomenal .

  • 5
    Vanilla Nut Fudge 3 slices

    Posted by L Jones on 6th Jul 2017

    This vanilla nut fudge is so absolutely delicious it should be ordered 3 slices (or more) at a time! It makes a great thank you gift and shipping was reasonable and fast too!

  • 5
    Fudge Is The Best, Shipping Could Be Better

    Posted by Tom M. from California on 26th Oct 2016

    Friends brought back some May's Fudge as a gift from their vacation. Loved it! Ordered the 3 Slice Fudge Set by mail. Product was just as good, however, shipping could be improved by either wrapping the fudge box to protect it in the flimsy shipping bag, OR, shipping the fudge box in a hard outer box. The fudge arrived a little "dented" and the box was pretty beat up from the shipping process. It didn't affect the good fudge thought.

  • 5
    Great Flavor - Fast Dhipping

    Posted by B Nummy on 29th Aug 2016

    May's Candy produces some of the best fudge I have ever tasted, smooth in texture and rich in flavor. I highly recommend!!

  • 5
    just like grannys :)

    Posted by Cayte M on 13th Aug 2016

    I have been buying Mayd PB fudge for years (15) over other competitors' products. No one else has the same taste or texture as my great grandma's fudge - and believe me, I've tried it all!! It brings back great memories, don't change a thing!! The cherry is also very delicious :) I had never done a mail order before but there were no issues as far as I could tell that impacted the flavor or quality. A great treat for home since we couldn't make it to the island this summer :)