Shipping & Returns

May's Guarantee of Satisfaction

Returns Policy

If for any reason you found the candy less than perfect, we will be happy to replace the candy. Simply mail the unused portion of the candy (postage cost will be refunded) with a breif explanation of why you felt it did not meet your expectations to:

May's Candy Shop
PO Box 483
Mackinac Island, MI 49757

For other questions please contact us via Contact page or call us at 906-847-6486.


We ship through Priority Mail. Once it's shipped, it generally takes about 3-4 business days to arrive since it takes an extra day to depart the island. Fudge won't melt during transit (takes about 160 F to melt fudge) so it should be fine. We carefully package our candies so it will arrive to the destination safely and preserved. If you have any questions please contact us!